Coquito de Nutella is a creamy holiday drink made with coconut milk, Nutella, and rum. It is served chilled and is absolutely delicious. Along with a plate of arroz con gandules, pernil and pasteles, Puerto Rican coquito is a staple during the holidays! If you love coquito and the taste of Nutella, save this recipe. This Nutella version does not disappoint!
Last year I got a little fancy and made the viral Christmas ornament cocktail (but with coquito) and they turned out FABULOUS! Check out my viral video to see how I made this festive holiday ornament cocktail! So many people have requested links to the items I used in the video! Here is the link to the cocktail glasses and ornaments.
This year I wanted to kick things up a notch and I made the viral Christmas ornament cocktail with four different flavors of coquito! Coconut, pistachio, Nutella, and strawberry.
What is coquito?
Coquito literally translates to “Little Coconut” in Spanish. It is a traditional holiday drink that originated in Puerto Rico. It is served from Thanksgiving through Christmas and sometimes up until Three Kings Day in January. This coconut cocktail is similar to eggnog and is often referred to as “Puerto Rican Eggnog” even though it doesn’t contain eggs.
Coquito de Nutella has all of the traditional flavors of coconut coquito with the rich, chocolatey flavor of Nutella. It is absolutely delicious!
It is believed that coquito originated in the 19th century after condensed milk was introduced in Puerto Rico. It is not clear who made the first coquito but the first published coquito recipes were in the Puerto Rican cookbooks “Cocine a Gusto” and “The Puerto Rican Cookbook,” between the years 1950 and 1970. After this, coquito’s popularity took off.
Ingredients for making coquito de Nutella:
The ingredients for coquito may vary by recipe but the main components are coconut milk, coconut cream and rum. Making coquito is quite similar to making limber de coco, another popular Puerto Rican treat! P.S. I’m convinced I have the BEST limber de coco recipe in the world, be sure to check it out. But let’s get back to this coquito de Nutella…
This version adds Nutella, cocoa powder, and hazelnut extract for a burst of rich nutty, chocolatey flavor!
- Coconut milk
- Cream of coconut
- Evaporated coconut milk
- Condensed coconut milk
- Hazelnut extract
- Light or dark rum
- Nutella
- Cocoa powder
How to make Nutella coquito?
Traditional coquito is infused with spices but for this recipe, you’ll want to skip the spices. Otherwise, the taste will overpower the flavor of the Nutella. By omitting spices in this coquito, you can really let the rich flavor of the Nutella really shine.
Add all of the coquito ingredients to a blender. Blend for about 30 seconds or until smooth.
Tip: If your blender is full to the brim, remove half of the coquito mixture and set aside. You can blend it with the rest later in a large bowl or pitcher.
Pour the coquito into a glass, airtight container. Store in the refrigerator for up to 3 weeks.
The coquito will thicken over time. Shake vigorously before serving. Serve coquito in a glass rimmed with chocolate syrup or condensed coconut milk and cocoa powder. Alternatively, you could rim the glass with coconut condensed milk, and coconut flakes.
What is the best rum for coquito?
You can use whichever type of rum you like. Some prefer light or dark. You can also try coconut or vanilla flavored rum. When choosing the right rum, it is really up to your preference!
You can also choose the quantity of rum to add to your coquito. If you like it light on the alcohol, start with 1/2 cup and build from there. Some people add 1-2 cups of rum. Again, it’s all up to you.
You could also omit the rum if you want to make virgin or non-alcoholic coquito. I always save a bottle of virgin coquito for my kids to enjoy. They feel happy when they can participate in the festivities too! Keep in mind, non-alcoholic coquito will not last as long because alcohol helps preserve it.
Can you make coquito vegan?
Yes, absolutely! In fact, my recipe is completely dairy-free and vegan. It does not contain eggs or milk products and it’s just as delicious as traditional coquito! If you are vegan or lactose intolerant, this recipe is for you.
I like to use Nature’s Charm brand evaporated and condensed coconut milk. Also, my favorite coconut milk is the Whole Foods 365 brand. It tastes delicious and has no weird aftertaste like Goya’s coconut milk. IYKYK. The best cream of coconut, in my opinion, is the Coco López brand. Using the best quality ingredients will result in the BEST tasting coquito, so it is worth spending a little extra!
If you want to make the traditional coquito recipe (non-vegan) just swap out the evaporated and condensed coconut milk for regular evaporated and condensed milk.
How to make homemade evaporated coconut milk?
If you can’t find evaporated coconut milk, you can make it at home with regular coconut milk! Just place coconut milk in a saucepan over low heat for 45 minutes to 1 hour, stirring occasionally. Heat until it reduces by half. Store in a glass jar in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks.
Please leave me a star rating or review!
If you enjoy this coquito de Nutella recipe, please leave me a 5 star review and also comment at the bottom of this blog post! Your feedback makes me so HAPPY! It also makes it easier for my recipes to be found on Google. THANK YOU in advance!
If you’d like my recipes sent straight to your inbox, subscribe to my email list here. Also, remember to tag me @madewithsazon in any photos of this recipe you post on social media. I love seeing your posts, it really makes my day!
Follow me on Instagram, YouTube, TikTok and Pinterest!
Coquito de Nutella (Nutella Coquito Recipe)
Equipment
- 1 Blender Ninja Foodi blender (see notes)
Ingredients
- 1 can coconut milk 13 oz
- 1 can cream of coconut 15 oz
- 2 cans evaporated coconut milk 12 oz each
- 1 can condensed coconut milk, sweetened 11 oz
- 1 tsp hazelnut extract
- 1 cup light or dark rum or to taste
- 3 tbsp Nutella
- 1 tbsp cocoa powder
Instructions
- Add all of the ingredients to a blender. Blend for about 30 seconds or until smooth.
- Pour the coquito into a glass, airtight container.
- Store in the refrigerator for up to 3 weeks.
- The coquito will thicken over time. Shake vigorously before serving.
- Serve coquito in a glass rimmed with chocolate syrup or condensed coconut milk, and cocoa powder. ¡Buen provecho!
Notes
Substitutions:
If you can’t find condensed coconut milk, you can use condensed oat milk instead. If you can’t find evaporated coconut milk, you can make it at home with regular coconut milk! Just heat coconut milk for 45 minutes to 1 hour until it reduces by half. One ingredient you cannot substitute is the cream of coconut, not to be confused with coconut cream. Cream of coconut is sweetened and its texture is like syrup. I like Goya or Coco Lopez brand.Garnish:
Make your coquito cocktail extra fancy by rimming your glass with chocolate syrup or condensed coconut milk, and cocoa powder.Rum:
You can use whichever type of rum you like. Some prefer light or dark. You can also add vanilla or coconut rum!Store:
Store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 3 weeks. Shake vigorously each time before serving!Shop my Amazon Favorites for this recipe:
I love using my Ninja Foodi Power Blender for making coquito, juice, smoothies, dough, even masa for pasteles and alcapurrias! It’s my favorite kitchen appliance ever! Shop my other favorite amazon items that I used for this recipe.Check out more holiday recipes!
Coquito (Vegan Coconut Eggnog)
Pastelón de Maduro (Plantain Lasagna)
Aceite de Achiote (Annatto Oil)
Jamón con Piña (Pineapple Glazed Ham)
Ensalada de Coditos (Macaroni Salad)
Ensalada de Papa (Potato Salad)
Pastel al Horno (Easy Pasteles)
Arroz con Gandules (Rice and Pigeon Peas)
Pavochón (Puerto Rican Style Turkey)
Pollo al Horno (Baked Chicken)
English 
Spanish 
